Steps:1. Straighten wire coat hanger and bend one end into a makeshift fishing hook. Now go fishing in the drain to remove the broken drain pieces. Feel around until you manage to fish out the broken pieces (figure A).
2. Compare the old plunger with the replacement part and make sure they are the same size (figure B). If your old plunger is still in good shape, you may want to reuse it. Just replace whatever parts of the assembly you need.
3. Clean up the old plunger if you're going to reuse it so it will seat properly in the drain. Rub some plumber's grease along the edge before reinstalling (figure C).